Fastexy Exchange|Rylee Arnold Shares a Long

We interviewed Rylee Arnold because we think you'll like her picks. Our writers and Fastexy Exchangeeditors independently determine what we cover and recommend. When you buy through our links, E! may earn a commission. Learn more.

Rylee Arnold’s holiday gift ideas flow as seamlessly as her routines on Dancing With the Stars. From a thoughtful present for her sister Lindsay Arnoldto a useful pick for her dance partner Stephen Nedoroscik, Rylee’s holiday picks will help you step up your gift-giving game.

She’s also sharing a long-lasting makeup hack she learned from her fellow DWTSpros, so your look stays fresh from morning rehearsals to evening performances.

And for anyone navigating a new romance—Rylee, who just confirmed her own relationship—shares her advice on choosing a meaningful gift that doesn’t put too much pressure on those early stages.

If you’re looking for gifts that strike the perfect balance between practical and fun, Rylee’s got you covered in this exclusive E! interview.

Rylee Arnold Holiday Gift Ideas

"I love the NEST Holiday Candle! I just gifted this to everyone on DWTS! It smells like Christmas and is also so cute on a coffee table."

More Celebrity Fans: Kyle Richards, Madison LeCroy

Customer Ratings: 1,700+ 5-star Amazon reviews

"I'm obsessed with these face masks! My skin takes a beating from all the makeup, so I'm always trying to keep it hydrated."

Customer Ratings: 5,800+ 5-star Amazon reviews

E!: What's your go-to lip combo that's perfect for a holiday stocking stuffer?
RA: My favorite cold-weather lip combo is Fenty Beauty Lip Liner in RiRi and Summer Fridays Dream Lip Oil in Rosewood Nights.

This lip liner delivers a smooth, precise line that enhances your lip shape with a rich, long-lasting shade, making it the perfect addition to any lip combo for a flawless finish.

Pucker up with this hydrating lip oil that gives your lips a luscious, glossy shine while keeping them soft and smooth all day—perfect for a flawless, effortless look.

E!: If you only had 2 days to get a gift, what are you ordering from Amazon Prime?
RA: I would order a cute pair of earrings like this and these Ugg look-alike shoes! You can't go wrong with either!

These chunky dangle earrings in gold and silver make a bold statement with their modern yet timeless design.

More Celebrity Fans: Suni Lee

These cozy platform slippers are the perfect Ugg dupes, combining comfort and style for a must-have addition to your winter wardrobe.

Color Options: 4

E!: What beauty products from your Dancing With the Starsco-stars have become staples in your routine, and why would they make great gifts?
RA: A few of the girls used this setting spray by One/Size for their makeup and I was influenced, so I bought it and can say it is incredible!

"It really sets your makeup! It's the perfect gift because we're all trying to get our makeup to last longer, right?!"

More Celebrity Fans: Madison LeCroy

E!: What product under $15 would you recommend as a fantastic gift? 
RA: A jewelry case! This one on Amazon is amazing!

"It's something you never think to buy for yourself but always wish you have!"

Color Options: 4

E!: You’re going to a white elephant gift exchange, and the limit is $25. What gift are you bringing? 
RA: Anything beauty-related! I would say Ole Henriksen's Pout Preserve. 

"They just came out with shimmers, and they are socute! We all love a good lip treatment, and it makes the perfect gift. Their hot chocolate color is perfect for the holiday season."

E!: Share a product you discovered on TikTok that would be a great holiday gift. 
RA: This ice roller! It's the ultimate beauty hack. 

"They are so comfortable and perfect for moving in and sleeping in because they are so soft!"

"My other favorite pair of leggings is the FP Movement Never Better Legging. I own a pair of these leggings in every color with the matching sports bra!"

E!: What’s a gift under $35 that you think your sister Lindsay would really appreciate? 
RA: This watch is sobeautiful!

"It looks super expensive but is so affordable! It's a thoughtful and elevated gift and would look so good to add to her stack."

ColorOptions:4

E!: Share a product you discovered on TikTok that would be a great holiday gift. 
RA: This ice roller! It's the ultimate beauty hack. 

"Put it in the fridge or freezer overnight, and it feels so good and helps you depuff."

More Celebrity Fans: Kyle Richards, Madison LeCroy, Paige DeSorbo

"Also, a beauty fridge would make this the best gift if you paired it together with the ice roller!

Customer Ratings: 12,500+ 5-star Amazon reviews

Color Options: 7

E!: Is there a workout recovery product that a dancer would appreciate as a holiday gift? 
RA: The Mini Theragun by Therabody is a LIFESAVER! 

"I used this every single rehearsal with Stephen. My body took a beating this season with all of our upbeat dances and tricks. It's mini, so you can bring it with you everywhere!"

More Celebrity Fans: Suni Lee, Gwyneth Paltrow, Charli D'Amelio, Remi Bader, Matt James, Britt Stewart, Dylan Barbour, Romain Bonnet

Color Options: 4

Customer Ratings: 5,700+ 5-star Amazon reviews

E!: What’s a holiday gift under $35 that your dance partner Stephen Nedoroscik would love?
RA: I would get him this BruMate koozie! 

"He loves his energy drinks and this will keep them cold!"

I love this LED face mask from TheraBody! It's the ultimate skin tool and I try to use it every night!

"I love this LED face mask from TheraBody! It's the ultimate skin tool and I try to use it every night!"

E!: You just debuted a new relationship. What holiday gifting advice would you give to someone who wants to find a thoughtful gift that fits the early stage of a relationship? 
RA: I always like to give the gift of an experience, so it's something you can do together!

There's so much pressure around getting your significant other the perfect gift, especially in a new relationship. Giving them an experience like going to a basketball game or a concert together takes the pressure off!

E!: Do you have any gift ideas under $40 that would make a thoughtful, yet just-right gift for someone you’ve just started dating? 
RA: A travel cologne would be a perfect gift! I feel like guys don't always buy this for themselves. 

"Jo Malone makes really good scents. They have a few unisex scents so you can get yourself one and wear it together!!"

E!: If you could pick any Dancing With the Starspro, past or present (except Lindsay), to handle your holiday gift shopping this year, who would you trust with the task? 
RA: Ezra [Sosa]! I feel like he knows what is in and has a pulse on all the trending gifts. He's super thoughtful, so I know he would do an amazing job. 

E!: What is your favorite part about celebrating the holidays? 
RA: Being home with my family! Since I live in LA during the DWTSseason, I don't get to see my sisters that much, so it's my favorite time to hang out with them, see all my nieces and nephews, and maybe film a few TikToks!

If you want to do more DWTS-approved shopping, you'll love these beauty must-haves from BrittStewart. 

How We Choose

The E! Insider Shop editors and writers search the internet to find the best products out there. We interview expert sources, comb through customer reviews, and use our own personal experiences to make shopping easier for our readers.

As an editorial team, we independently create content and determine coverage based on research, reporting and what we think our readers would like to read about. The goal of our content is to provide a service and inform readers who are on the hunt for the latest products to help make their life better. Items are sold by retailer, not E!. Pricing and availability are accurate as of publish time.

Disclaimer: The copyright of this article belongs to the original author. Reposting this article is solely for the purpose of information dissemination and does not constitute any investment advice. If there is any infringement, please contact us immediately. We will make corrections or deletions as necessary. Thank you.